Choosing between an Instance and a Tenant
Decide whether a new requirement needs a separate DataOS Instance or a Tenant in an existing one.
When a new requirement comes in, the first decision is whether it should be served by a separate DataOS Instance or by a Tenant within an existing Instance.
This decision depends on isolation, governance, infrastructure control, workload behavior, and cost. In most cases, a Tenant is the right starting point. A separate Instance is more appropriate when strict separation or independent control is required.
Evaluation criteria
Work through these questions in order. The first "yes" that points to a clear outcome is usually the right answer.
1. Business context
Is the requirement a proof of concept, pilot, or focused data initiative?
Yes: Choose a Tenant with shared compute.
No: Continue to the next question.
2. Security and compliance
Does the environment require strict infrastructure isolation?
Yes: Choose a separate Instance.
No: Continue.
3. Cross-organizational access
Will the environment include users from other departments, external vendors, or consultants?
Yes: Choose a separate Instance.
No: Continue.
4. Infrastructure control
Does the operating team need full control over upgrades, maintenance schedules, and platform operations?
Yes: Choose a separate Instance.
No: Continue.
5. Cost efficiency
Is shared infrastructure a higher priority than dedicated resources?
No: Choose a separate Instance.
Yes: Continue.
6. Workload predictability
Are workloads predictable and unlikely to affect neighboring Tenants?
Yes: Choose a Tenant with shared compute.
No: Choose a separate Instance.
Quick reference
Proof of concept or focused data initiative
Tenant with shared compute
Strict infrastructure isolation
Separate Instance
Cross-department or external participants
Separate Instance
Full upgrade and maintenance control
Separate Instance
Cost efficiency through shared infrastructure
Tenant (evaluate further)
Predictable workloads, low neighbor impact
Tenant with shared compute
Summary
Use a Tenant when the requirement benefits from shared platform operations, lower cost, faster setup, and controlled reuse of existing infrastructure.
Use a separate Instance when the requirement calls for strict isolation, independent infrastructure control, or broader boundary separation across organizations.
This is a governance and operating model decision, not only an infrastructure decision.
Last updated
Was this helpful?